I don't know just how much the little kids really bought, but they sure seemed to swallow the story hook, line, and sinker. The main reason was we had all the trappings right. It looked and sounded like a space launch in their limited experience.
When you are talking about faith and opposing worldviews, many Christians can be just as gullible as the second graders in my story above. They will hear an objection or an argument and because it sounds like a real objection, they assume it is a serious issue. However, the mature Christian will be able to identify what are known as logical fallacies. Fallacies are not real arguments. They're smoke-and mirrors tricks that are not evidence of someone's position. I've reviewed a couple of these before, but I'd like to quickly go through some of the more common ones below.
1. Genetic FallacyThe genetic fallacy is any argument that draws a conclusion due to an irrelevant aspect of the source. An example I've often used is of an elementary school teacher who taught children their multiplication tables. Imagine that later this teacher was convicted of perjury. Since the teacher is a proven liar, does that mean the children should now not believe that 2x2=4? Just because the source of that fact has been shown to be flawed, it doesn't mean that the particular point you are arguing is flawed, too. Here are some examples of the genetic fallacy:
- "You are a Christian because you were raised in a Christian country."
- "Because the Bible is an ancient document, it can't be relevant to today."
- "Too many Christian hypocrites have told me the same thing that you're saying."
2. Argumentum ad PopulumArgumentum ad Populum, or arguing to the people is saying because an opinion or position is the popular one, it should therefore be believed. However, the popularity of a position doesn't make the position true. Slavery was accepted in the early period of the United States, but that doesn't mean it was right or moral. Here are some examples of argumentum ad populum:
- "Everyone believes evolution is true."
- "The vast majority of scientists don't believe in God."
3. Argumentum ad HominemArgumentum ad Hominem means arguing to the man, and it happens when a person attacks the person for some inconsequential reason. While the most well-known version of the fallacy would include an insult ("You're too stupid for me to believe that!"), many times the ad Hominem argument is more subtle. For example, a Democrat that rejects any statement offered by a Republican because of his party affiliation is committing a type of the ad Hominem fallacy. Here are a couple more:
- "I can't listen to you about abortion. How can you possibly know how a woman feels since you're a man?"
- "Christianity can't be believed. I mean, look at what the Christians did in the Crusades!"
4. False DilemmaA false dilemma is when you are offered two choices as the only two possibilities, while more really exist.
- "Either you accept outdated beliefs or you hold to reason."
- "I would rather place my trust in science than faith."
5. Straw ManSometimes people will either oversimplify Christian beliefs or completely misstate what Christians believe. Just as a scarecrow stuffed with straw is easier to knock over than a real man, some will construct a straw man of the Christian's beliefs just to more easily knock them down. (For a fuller explanation of a straw man, see this.) Here are a few straw men that you may recognize:
- "All you Bible-believing nuts want to be slain in the spirit and protest against homosexuals"
- "Everything needs a cause. God is a thing, so what caused him?"
6. Appeal to PityAppeals to pity are simply trying to not argue on the reasons for a position but rather on making someone feel bad. It tries to play on people's emotions rather than the facts of the matter. You can see this used all the time in political campaigns, where candidates will offer one or two anecdotes of a person who is in a tough spot and then argue that certain policies need to be adopted "to help her out of this difficult time." It's a tug on the heartstrings instead of looking at the argument itself. Here are some more examples:
- "If abortion is not legalized, then only the rich will be able to get abortions."
- "Accepting Christianity would mean that there are more people in Hell than in Heaven. That's a monstrous belief."