I remember the first time I heard the story of the Las Vegas vacationer who
took a girl back to his hotel room but passed out, only to awake the next
morning in a bathtub filled with ice and a kidney missing—the victim of organ
harvesters. I had heard it from a co-worker who said it happened to the friend
of a shared friend. Since this was before the age of the Internet, there was no
Snopes–type web sites to check out such tales. In fact, I hadn't been
acquainted with many urban legends up to that point, so in my youth they were
more believable.
I should have known better. While the name of our shared
friend lent some credence to the tale, it's obvious that the whole this is too
sensationalistic and improbable to be true. It's what used to be called a tall
tale, a yarn, a cock-and-bull story. Yet, even though I found it fascinating,
the legend didn't spread much beyond our conversation. However, now that social
media has been implanted into our circulatory systems, we're much more apt to
spread such fertilizer in our interactions with others.
The Horus-Jesus Myth: What's the Connection?
Such is the case with the "Jesus is a copy of pagan myths" trope that seems
to be gathering steam in many atheist circles. Some of this has to do with the
popularity of the YouTube video Zeitgeist, where the first third of the video
tries to compare Jesus and several demi-gods worshipped prior to Jesus's birth.
Near the beginning, the narrator makes this claim:
Broadly speaking, the story of Horus is as follows: Horus was born on
December 25th of the virgin Isis-Meri. His birth was accompanied by a star
in the east, which in turn, three kings followed to locate and adorn the
new-born savior. At the age of 12, he was a prodigal child teacher, and at
the age of 30 he was baptized by a figure known as Anup and thus began his
ministry. Horus had 12 disciples he traveled about with, performing miracles
such as healing the sick and walking on water. Horus was known by many
gestural names such as The Truth, The Light, God's Annointed Son, The Good
Shepherd, The Lamb of God, and many others. After being betrayed by Typhon,
Horus was crucified, buried for 3 days, and thus, resurrected.
These
attributes of Horus, whether original or not, seem to permeate in many
cultures of the world, for many other gods are found to have the same
general mythological structure.1
Richard Carrier also believes that resurrection stories were "wildly popular
among the pagans" and begat a something akin to the standard trope, with the
Gospels simply following in this tradition:
Among pagans, genuine sons of god who had to be murdered, buried, and then
miraculously resurrected from the dead in order to judge and rule from
heaven on high as our divine saviors were actually a common fad of the time,
not a shocking novelty at all. Osirus and Romulus were widely worshipped to
the tune of such sacred stories demonstrably before the rise of
Christianity, and similar stories surrounded other dying-and-rising gods
long before such as Zalmoxis, Adonis, and Inanna.2
The Horus-Jesus Myth: Be Critical
Just like the stolen kidney story, the Horus-Jesus connection myth has much of
what makes an urban legend appealing: a moral tale that shows how one's
gullibility can result in one being taken in with serious consequences, the
authoritative yet undefined source, a set of facts that on the surface are
seemingly plausible, and the ability to shock others with a sensational
revelation. Yet, just like the stolen kidney story, all you need to do is to
think a bit and the paper-thin claims of Jesus's stolen resurrection will
quickly melt away. Here are five points to consider:
1)
Look for Loaded Language
Notice in the Zeitgeist story, all the terms used
are ones taken from Christianity. Horus is called a "messiah" and was
"baptized." He had "disciples" and a "ministry." All of these terms bias the
listener because they are Jewish or Christian concepts. The Egyptians would
never use these words to refer to their religious rites. The word messiah had a
very specific meaning to the Jews, including being a descendant of David. It
wasn't any political figure. Christianity teaches that believers are baptized
only once, not simply a pre-religious washing ceremony. By mislabeling other
deities with Christian terms, the listener is deluded into believing the
similarities are closer than they really are.
2)
Ask "Can I read the source of these myths?"
The single easiest way to debunk
these supposed parallel accounts of Jesus and Horus are to simply ask for the
source text of the myths themselves. Just as the stolen kidney tale can't be
verified since it comes from "a friend of a friend," so you'll find that the
ancient tales that supposedly parallels the life of Jesus are an extended form
of hearsay. In fact, all these claims are usually committing the same sin many
atheists claim the Gospels commit: they are more like a game of telephone than
real texts.
Interestingly, if anyone actually bothers to look up the
source texts, a very different picture arises. For Horus, there's no mention at
all of twelve disciples, three king visitations, and death by crucifixion and
the three day entombment. In fact, Horus was stung by a scorpion and a magic
incantation by the god of wisdom, Thoth, purges the venom from his body. This
all happens while Horus was a young child, well before his adulthood and battle
for the throne. It's nothing like Jesus's resurrection at all.
3
3) Ask "What do you mean by "resurrection?"
There's a significant difference between Jesus's resurrection and what you
read in the ancient myths. Osirus, according to a late tradition recorded in the
first century AD by the Roman Plutarch, was cut into fourteen pieces by his
nemesis Typhon and they were scattered all along the Nile. Osirus's wife Isis
was able to gather thirteen of those to reassemble her husband. The tale tells
us that unfortunately Osirus's sexual organ was eaten by fish and so Isis
assembled another out of gold in order for Osirus to impregnate her with Horus.
Osirus, since he will never be a complete being again, now resides as the god of
the underworld.
4
4) Ask "What do you mean by virgin birth?"
Certainly, given the events above,
calling Horus's conception a virgin birth strains the idea to its breaking
point. Other fables, such as Zeus impregnating Semele with Dionysus. He had
physical relations with her even though she couldn't see him. Zeus took
Dionysus as a fetus and sewed him into his thigh and from there Dionysus was
born. To say the virgin birth stories should be considered comparable is itself
laughable.
5) Ask "Just which calendar
were they using in ancient Egypt?"
Lastly, the claims of December 25th are
completely erroneous. Many myths don't specify any date at all for the birth of
the deities (again, read the originals!) For Horus, Plutarch tells us he was
born "about the time of the winter solstice… imperfect and premature."
5
Beside the fact that Plutarch mixed many Greek ideas with the Egyptian myths, it
is a huge stretch to assume an exact date for Horus's birth. Taking Plutarch's
account, the term "about the time of the winter solstice" can be a swing of
weeks in either direction. But if the Egyptians wanted to be more precise and
attach Horus with the solstice, then his birthday would be the 21/22 of December
in the modern calendar, not the 25th. As I've explained before, Jesus's
actual birth is not known, and celebrating Christmas on December 25
has nothing to do with the winter solstice whatsoever.
There are
other ideas you should have at the ready as well. For more suggestions, see
here
and
here. But it should be
evident by now that the supposed evidence of Christianity's plagiarism of
earlier myths is itself based on myths and contrivances. Those that offer such
views attempt to paint a picture that doesn't exist. Don't let these organ
thieves steal your brain. Challenge them to think.
References
